14 Underrated Episodes Of Smallville That Deserve More Appreciation
Audiences often groan at having to sit through yet another superhero origin story, especially one that's already so embedded in pop culture that even people who've never read a comic book in their lives could describe it. The CW's "Smallville," which takes a look at the formative years of Clark Kent before he became Superman, could've fallen into the trap of repeating so many of the same story elements that we're all so familiar with. And yet, the series — which launched in 2001 and ended in 2011 — managed to wring a lot of great material out of Clark's early days and, for the most part, maintain its high quality over the course of 10 seasons.
Part of what made "Smallville" work so well was its creators' ability to fuse the teen drama that made the CW so popular with young people during the network's heyday with thrilling superheroics and action set pieces. While the series experienced some ups and downs throughout its decade-long run, every season produced at least a few classic episodes that epitomized just how great a character Superman really is. Of course, there were also plenty of episodes that, despite being largely overlooked by fans at the time, are better than we remember. So, let's take a look at a few of those, shall we?
Spell — Season 4, Episode 8
This episode opens with three witches who are about to be burned at the stake in France in 1604. Magistrate Wilkins interrogates one of them, Margaret Isobel Thoreaux, as to the whereabouts of the fabled Stones of Power, but she remains tightlipped and is consigned to a fiery death with the other witches. However, just before Isobel's execution, she spits on her spellbook and vows to return. Centuries later, Lana Lang, a descendent of Isobel, buys that very same spellbook online and soon becomes possessed by her foremother. Isobel resurrects her old witchy peers, and they resume their search for the Stones of Power, which are of Kryptonian origin.
"Young Superman fights a trio of witches" may sound gimmicky at first, but the episode wonderfully marries black magic to the show's sci-fi-oriented elements. "Spell" feels very much like a tribute to the original "Superboy" comics run, which saw a young Clark Kent embark on more whimsical adventures than his older counterpart. Lana, Chloe Sullivan, and Lois Lane delight as the witches Isobel, Madelyn Hibbins, and Brianna Withridge, respectively, with their crashing of a birthday party at the Kent barn a high point of the episode.
Cool — Season 1, Episode 5
Clark Kent and Chloe Sullivan go to a party at Crater Lake for a typical high school good time. Annoying jock Sean Kelvin puts the moves on Chloe. She's not too impressed but gives him her number just so he'll leave her alone. Later on at the party, Sean falls into the frozen lake, which happens to have some kryptonite fragments in it. After seemingly dying, Sean reemerges, but with a fierce cold and the ability to freeze anyone and anything he comes into contact with. He needs warmth from the bodies of others, leading to his girlfriend Jenna's death. Next on his list: Chloe.
Sean serves as a great villain-of-the-week, and because of his powers' origins, also makes for a sort of anti-Superman. We glimpse how superhuman abilities amplify a person's character, and how they can corrupt an already-selfish person. The special effects, for the most part, hold up quite well, and do a great job of illustrating the dangers of Sean's new gifts. Additionally, we get some nice character development here: the usual teen drama when Clark finally musters the courage to ask out Lana (with some help from Lex Luthor) and welcome fleshing out of the complicated relationship between Clark's parents and Lex.
Lineage — Season 2, Episode 7
This episode kicks off with a mysterious woman wandering into the Kent house while they're away. She gazes at photographs of Clark, then later confronts him at school with some startling news: she's his real mother. Clark and his parents meet with the woman, Rachel Dunleavy, who gives them some information from years earlier that reveals Clark as her son. The Kents don't buy it and tell her to leave them alone. However, Rachel is determined to win Clark over and asks Lex for help by giving him some startling news: Lex and Clark are biological brothers.
"Lineage" is light on action, but heavy on drama and familial complications. There's enough juicy paternity turmoil here to fill a season of "Maury." While this episode feels a little melodramatic at times, it more than makes up for it with its shocking twists and turns. Highlights include flashbacks to the original meteor shower that accompanied Clark's arrival on Earth and how it impacted the Luthor family. But Clark and Lex aren't the only ones who learn more about their pasts; Lana and Chloe are given a much-needed chance to explore their true parentage as well.
Talisman — Season 3, Episode 20
Professor Joseph Willowbrook and his graduate student assistant Jeremiah Holdsclaw arrive at the Kawatche Caves upon the request of Lionel Luthor, who wants them to identify a strange relic found there. Jeremiah smashes the object, revealing it to be a sacred blade that grants him superhuman powers comparable to Clark's, and escapes. Professor Willowbrook posits that Clark is part of an ancient prophecy associated with the blade, the same prophecy that prompts Jeremiah to believe that Lionel is his destined enemy who must be killed.
Seeing Superman (or, in this case, a young Clark) go up against villains who possess the exact same power set on screen and in the comics is often boring, as it usually devolves into a punching contest. However, the climactic Clark-Jeremiah showdown is actually stellar and puts their equal abilities to creative use. Jeremiah's a one-off villain, but Nathaniel Arcand creates an adequate antagonist. Though "Talisman" falls into the action episode category, it offers some nice developments in the characters' relationships, most notably Lex's feelings for Lana. He might be a narcissistic and manipulative jerk, but we can't help but be a little touched by his genuine desire to spend time with her.
Resurrection — Season 3, Episode 15
Clark's friend Garrett is mourning his brother Vince's death from liver failure. However, Vince's body is sent to the Metropolis lab of molecular biologist Lia Teng, who injects him with a mysterious serum that instantly revives him. Vince returns to Smallville, much to Garrett's shock, but he quickly keels over from his liver condition. He's taken to the hospital, where his state worsens. Garrett refuses to watch his brother die again. He straps a bomb to himself and demands his brother be given a liver transplant. However, this occurs right when Jonathan Kent is undergoing an urgent triple bypass surgery at the same hospital.
Okay, so the overall plot is kind of forced, as Clark just happened to be friends with someone who also had a family member in serious condition at the same hospital, and he just happened to show up at the hospital at the exact same time Jonathan was to be operated on. Still, look past the coincidences and it's a very suspenseful episode with incredibly high stakes, which are all the more heightened considering Clark's touching relationship with his adoptive parents. "Resurrection" surprises with both a delightfully tantalizing mystery that revolves around Teng's experiments on Clark's blood and a surprising connection between Ting and Lionel.
Lockdown — Season 5, Episode 11
Two police officers barge into Lex's home and warn him of a supposed bomb threat. However, Lex believes they're lying and escapes into a panic room. One of the police officers then reveals that he survived the second meteor shower that ravaged Smallville and explains that he suspects Lex knows the location of the spaceship connected with it. The other police officer kidnaps Lana and brings her to Lex's manor to coerce him into leaving his panic room. A scuffle breaks outs and Lex frees Lana, but not before one of the officers shoots him in the chest. Clark rescues Lex and takes him to a hospital. Lana is still the police officers' hostage, and with a bomb about to go off, Clark has only seconds to save her life.
The tension ratchets up to 11 in "Lockdown" and it does so scene by scene. This episode brilliantly balances complicated romance between Lex and Lana, and the escalating conflict right outside the panic room involving the manic police officers. As expected, Clark saves the day in a suitably explosive climax. But the ending is given an extra dose of dramatic weight when Lana mistakenly believes, because of Clark's superspeed, that Lex is the one who saved her life. Clark is too honorable to reveal the truth, but also realizes that he could win her heart if he told her who he really is.
Fragile — Season 5, Episode 18
Naomi is the foster mother of a young mute girl named Maddie who can shatter glass with her mind. When Maddie becomes distressed, she shatters all the glass in their house, seemingly killing Naomi. Maddie is taken to the Kent farm where Clark develops a friendship with her as he, too, knows the struggle of controlling one's powers. Clark, believing that Maddie isn't responsible for Naomi's death, meets with Chloe to look into her parentage. However, Maddie's biological father, who shares her power, has just escaped from jail and is eager to be with his daughter.
Tom Welling directed this episode and proves that he's as talented behind the camera as he is in front of it. "Fragile" is at its best during the scenes between Clark and Maddie; one of Superman's greatest qualities is his propensity to see the good in everybody, and Clark's emotionally resonant relationship with Maddie pays tribute to that very quality. Welling treats the material with considerable tenderness, giving us a story that's touching but not sappy, while demonstrating that he truly understands his character inside and out.
Noir — Season 6, Episode 20
Jimmy Olsen convinces Chloe to watch the classic noir film, "The Big Sleep," with him one night in the basement of the Daily Planet. However, the screening is interrupted by the sound of a gunshot and the appearance of a critically wounded Lana in the elevator. A mysterious figure then dashes away from the scene, but not before Jimmy snaps a picture of them with his phone. Before Jimmy can download the image, though, he's knocked out — only to reawaken in a black-and-white 1940s world wherein he's an ace reporter covering a murder case ... accompanied by a clumsy Clark as his trusty sidekick.
"Noir" does little to develop Season 6's overarching plot, yet it makes for an amusing diversion. The episode's creators wring a surprising amount of clever ideas out of the 1940s noir film setting, ensuring it never devolves into a cheap gag. Welling's turn as a bungling reporter version of Clark is a wonderful nod to the character's portrayal of yore, and Kreuk hams it up as a classic femme fatale. The only real problem with this episode is the wraparound plot, which feels like an afterthought compared to Jimmy's black-and-white dream, although it is fun seeing him still carry the hard-nosed detective bit when he comes to in the real world.
Fierce — Season 7, Episode 3
Clark shows his cousin Kara Kent (real name: Kara Zor-El) around Smallville and tries to convince her to not attract attention to herself as she still hasn't fully mastered her powers. Kara wants to fit in with the other humans of Earth, though, and enlists in the town's yearly "Miss Sweet Corn" beauty pageant. However, three gorgeous yet superpowered women show up in Smallville and wreak havoc during their search for a legendary treasure trove said to reside in the town's time capsule.
"Fierce" is a little on the corny side (pun absolutely intended), but the episode is a pleasant break from the more somber and intense storylines that preceded it. The villains are somewhat forgettable, yet the real charm of the episode comes from Clark's relationship with Kara, who he struggles to teach how to adapt to life on Earth. Laura Vandervoort shines as the effervescent Kara, playing her with equal parts heart and impulsiveness.
Fracture — Season 7, Episode 12
Missing since the battle with Zor-El, Kara's tracked down by Lois. Unfortunately, Kara can't remember anything and now works at a small restaurant. She attracts the attention of the busboy, Finley, but his affection for her soon becomes an obsession. He shoots Lex when he arrives at the diner, fearing he's there to take Kara away from him. Clark, desperate to find Lois and Kara, uses a piece of experimental LuthorCorp equipment to enter Lex's mind for answers.
Lex has pretty much gone full villain by this point in the series, but the episode's creators go to great lengths to reveal to the viewer the complex layers of his mind –- literally. We see the obvious dark and twisted sides of Lex, such as when we're shown how his love for Lana is couched in his desire to make Clark suffer. However, a small part of his goodness still resides within his psyche, desperately calling out to be genuinely loved. Despite his massive ego, all Lex cared about was hearing his father tell him that he loved him.
Beast — Season 8, Episode 20
Chloe seemingly killed Davis Bloome, but this is a ruse that Clark uncovers. He believes that he can get rid of Davis once and for all by banishing him to the Phantom Zone. However, Chloe continues to lie to him about Davis' whereabouts. Davis is about to murder Oliver Queen (also known as Green Arrow) when Clark steps in, intent on whisking Davis to the Fortress of Solitude. Chloe then thwarts Clark's plan, as she believes that there's still hope for Davis.
Davis represents "Smallville"'s interpretation of the classic villain, Doomsday, and while we only see a little bit of his monstrous side in the series, he's still one of the better antagonists. His deep love for Chloe keeps him in check, adding a tragic dimension to a character who, in the hands of lesser writers, would simply be a force of mindless destruction. Clark displays some more complexity here, as well, as his endless hope for even the most dangerous of enemies falters. Sometimes the best of us need a reminder to do what's right.
Persuasion — Season 9, Episode 13
Much to Clark's annoyance, he and Lois spend their Valentine's Day pursuing a story. He hoped to do something romantic. Lois, however, hates the superficiality of the holiday and refuses to celebrate. But Clark is soon stricken by gemstone kryptonite, which enables him to influence people to do his bidding. When he tells Lois that he wants them to have a more old-fashioned romantic life, she ends her career as a reporter and takes on a role akin to a 1950s housewife. And when Clark informs Chloe he wants her to watch his back, she sets out to protect him from Lois.
Erica Durance amuses as the typically determined Lois, who instantly turns into June Cleaver. And Allison Mack's overly vigilant Chloe deserves praise here, too. It's a testament to how well-defined these characters are that seeing them act in a manner completely opposite to their usual portrayals brings such delight. "Persuasion" falls short of perfection only because of Zod's storyline which, while interesting, clashes too much with the more lighthearted hijinks of Clark's new brainwashing abilities. Zod's presence ups the ante, but his arc's continuation deserves its own episode.
Collateral — Season 10, Episode 12
Clark and his friends were mysteriously knocked out at Carter Hall's funeral in Egypt. They then reawaken with jumbled memories and stripped of their powers. They suspect that Chloe is behind their current state, but she reveals the government rendered them comatose. Why? The government intends to control their powers and has placed their minds in a digitally-created world. Chloe helps each of them break out of their artificial worlds that were developed as part of a wider plot involving the Vigilante Registration Act.
"Collateral" is a total ripoff of "The Matrix," but that's not a criticism. Sure, there are plenty of stylishly choreographed fight scenes and liberal use of the bullet-time effect, but the plot moves at such a brisk pace that there's no time to quibble over the heavy borrowing of the beloved sci-fi action film. Also, Chloe had been gone for most of the season, so it's nice seeing her pop up again. In fact, her long absence raised some questions about what she'd been up to, so her unexpected reappearance keeps you guessing about whether she's still on the side of the angels or if she actually is working with the government.
Conspiracy — Season 9, Episode 14
Bernard Chisholm carries out his revenge against the Kandorian scientists who performed experiments on him by kidnapping them and coercing Lois Lane to write a story about them. Even without his powers, Zod hunts down Bernard to rescue the Kandorians but is shot, leaving it up to Clark to save the hostages. While he's too late to save Zod's life, Clark uses his own blood to revive him, which ends their animosity. The two promise to aid the Kandorians in their transition to Earth life, but Zod secretly hides the fact that Clark's blood also resurrected his powers.
Zod may be hellbent on world domination, but the deep love he has for his people elevates him above a cartoony, mustache-twirling supervillain. His decision to rescue his people, even in his depowered state, shows just how noble he truly is. A high point occurs when Clark chooses — fatefully — to save Zod. He knows the danger Zod presents and that letting him die will make the world safer, but, just like the Superman he eventually becomes, Clark never shies away from the chance to show someone a better way.